In Brief

  • The modern revival has brought new pressure on the peoples and plants that kept these sacraments, and Indigenous-led efforts now work to protect land, plants, and knowledge on their own terms.
  • Peyote is the clearest case. Its decline has been traced to outside use, careless harvest, poaching, and Native peoples' loss of access to the land where it grows.
  • Real reciprocity lets the keepers of a tradition decide what help looks like, and sometimes it means staying away.

Reverence and Reciprocity tells how this knowledge reached the wider world, and what it cost the peoples who kept it. This volume concerns the present, in which the cost is still being paid, and the work of those trying to stop it.

The Cost of Attention

Every wave of outside enthusiasm brings visitors, buyers, and imitators to communities that never asked for them. The Little Saints tells what the first wave did to one mountain village. Attested The present revival in research, retreats, and commerce has been no exception, and the more these sacraments are praised, the harder it becomes to protect the plants, places, and ceremonies at their source.

In response a number of organizations have formed, many of them led by Indigenous people, to protect what is at risk. We describe their work without naming them, as is our rule. The descriptions are plain enough to lead you to them.

The Cactus That Cannot Be Hurried

Peyote grows wild only in southern Texas and northern Mexico, and it takes many years to mature. Attested It is the sacrament of peoples who have no substitute for it, and who won a measure of legal protection for their prayers only after generations of raids and prosecutions. Attested

In 2017 an Indigenous-led initiative was founded to conserve the plant and to protect the spiritual relationship between Native communities and their sacrament. It names the causes of decline plainly: use by people outside the Native tradition; harvesting that kills the plant instead of allowing it to regrow; illegal poaching; and changes in land ownership that have cut Native people off from the places where it grows. Attested Its work includes replanting, education in sustainable harvest, and the pursuit of changes in policy, and it works alongside the peyote church of North America. Attested

For everyone else, the counsel of this library has not changed: leave it to them. A plant that needs many years to mature cannot meet the appetite of a curious world.

Reciprocity on Their Own Terms

One institute, which describes its purpose as "protecting sacred plants" and "advancing psychedelic justice," runs a reciprocity initiative that funds grassroots, Indigenous-led projects across the Americas. Its focus is the protection of land, of traditional knowledge, and of what it calls biocultures: the living weave of a people with the plants and places they belong to. Its stated principle is that resources should reach communities "on their own terms and priorities." Attested

That phrase is worth more than any donation. Outsiders who wish to give back often arrive with a plan, and the plan is usually theirs. Reciprocity that deserves the name begins by asking what is wanted and accepting the answer, even when the answer is "nothing from you" or "please stay away."

The same institute works to amplify Latin American voices in a field that has often talked over them, publishes guidance on religious freedom, and offers harm-reduction resources for communities that practice ceremonially together. Attested The library it keeps includes studies of peyote's history, traditions, politics, and conservation; a bibliography of the ayahuasca religions; and collections on women, queer people, and justice in psychedelic culture. Attested

Living Traditions, Not Relics

It is easy to speak of "Indigenous traditions" as if they were museum pieces. They are not. They change, argue, adapt, and resist. In northeastern Brazil the Jurema tradition, rooted in Indigenous and Afro-Brazilian spiritual practice and long a form of resistance, now finds itself at a crossroads between its own knowledge and that of the sciences. Attested Ayahuasca, carried out of the Amazon, has given rise to organized religions whose churches now stand on several continents. Attested

A living tradition has the right to change in its own way, and also the right to refuse the changes others would wish upon it. Our part as outsiders is to listen to what its keepers say now, and not to what we imagine they said long ago.

What Is Meant by Psychedelic Justice

The phrase "psychedelic justice" has entered the field's vocabulary in recent years. Those who use it generally mean several things at once: that the peoples who kept these sacraments should share in any benefit drawn from them; that the communities punished most heavily under prohibition should not be shut out of whatever lawful access follows it; and that women, queer people, people of color, and others long absent from the field's leadership should have a voice in its future. Attested Courses, books, and directories of minority-led communities now gather around these themes. Attested

Not everyone agrees on what justice requires in practice, and this library takes no side in the field's quarrels over policy. We note only that the questions are serious, and that a seeker who benefits from these sacraments inherits a share of them.

Questions Before You Give

If you wish to support this work, as we hope many readers will, these questions may help. They are drawn from Reading the Signposts, which applies them more widely.

  1. Is the effort led by the people it serves, or by outsiders speaking for them?
  2. Does the money reach communities directly, and on their terms?
  3. Does the organization publish its accounts and say how its decisions are made?
  4. Does it sell ceremonies, plants, or experiences drawn from the very traditions it says it protects?
  5. Would the community welcome your attention, or only your absence?

Some programs that bring outsiders to ceremonies abroad describe gifts to local communities as part of what they do. That may be generous, and it may also be a way of purchasing permission. Ask the question set out in Reverence and Reciprocity: whether the hosts truly want you there.

About the Keeper

Imogen Lark, Keeper of the Threshold

Imogen is the library's editor and the first voice most seekers meet. She keeps the catalog, the glossary, and the path for new readers, and she sees that every correction is made.