What Is Being Described
Read the testimony of contemplatives from any age, and then read the journals of people returning from a deep visionary journey, and you will often be unable to tell which is which. The same phrases recur. Everything was one. Time stopped. I was held. I understood, though I cannot say what I understood. It was more real than this.
Scholars of religion have studied such reports for more than a century and have found a family resemblance among them. Attested Not every experience has every feature, and some experiences have none. Still, the pattern is steady enough to describe.
The Common Features
- Unity. The boundary between self and world thins or vanishes. Some feel it inwardly, as a dissolving into pure awareness. Others feel it outwardly, as a recognition that every leaf and face is made of one life.
- Sacredness. Whatever is met is felt to be holy and worthy of reverence, whether or not the person has any religious language for it.
- Deeply felt peace and joy. Often a love so complete that people weep for hours.
- The noetic quality. A conviction that something true has been shown, not merely felt. This is knowledge by acquaintance, the way one knows a friend.
- Timelessness. Past and future fall away. People speak of eternity not as endless time but as no time at all.
- Ineffability. Words fail. Those who try anyway reach for paradox: a fullness that was empty, a darkness that shone.
- Transiency. It passes. The ordinary world returns, and the memory remains.
What Careful Study Has Found
In the spring of 1962, a now famous experiment gave either psilocybin or a comparison substance to divinity students during a religious service. Nearly all who received the sacrament reported experiences with the features above, and when they were sought out about twenty-five years later, they still regarded that day as a genuine and lasting high point of their spiritual lives. Attested The same follow-up found that at least one participant had passed through real terror, which the first report had played down. Attested Both halves of that story deserve to be remembered.
When research resumed in the early 2000s under far stricter conditions, the pattern held. In one widely discussed study, roughly two thirds of volunteers rated a supervised session among the five most meaningful experiences of their lives, alongside the birth of a child or the death of a parent. Attested Later work has repeatedly found that the more fully mystical the experience, the more lasting its benefits tend to be. Attested
Notice the conditions. These volunteers were carefully screened, patiently prepared, never left alone, and helped afterward. The setting was part of the sacrament. See Set, Setting and Sacred Containers.
Other Kinds of Holy Meeting
Not every sacred experience is one of unity. Many seekers report encounter instead: a presence, an ancestor, a teacher, the spirit of the plant itself, a goddess at a crossroads. Witches and animists have long spoken this language, and it is no lesser tongue. The mystic says, "I and the holy are one." The witch says, "I met someone, and we spoke." Both may be telling the truth.
And many journeys are neither. They are quiet, or bodily, or full of ordinary memory. A journey without fireworks is not a failure. Often it is the one that does the most patient good.
Holding the Gift
A mystical experience can inflate a person as easily as it can humble one. The surest protection is to treat the vision as a gift and never as a credential. It does not make you a teacher. It does not make you right. It does not settle the questions that the wisest people in every tradition have left open.
We suggest three practices for the weeks afterward.
- Write down what happened in plain words before you interpret it. See The Journey Journal.
- Tell it to one trusted and grounded person, not to everyone. A chaplain or other trained spiritual companion can be such a person; see The Chaplain's Chair.
- Ask what it requires of you on an ordinary weekday. That answer is the real revelation.