The history of cannabis in the Islamic world is a history of argument. It is preserved for us almost entirely in the writings of people who disapproved of it, which is a fact a historian must keep firmly in mind. We hear the dervishes mostly through the mouths of their critics.
What the Law Said
The Quran forbids wine and does not mention cannabis. Attested Muslim jurists reasoned from wine to other intoxicants by analogy, and they cited a saying of the Prophet: what intoxicates in large amounts is forbidden in small amounts too. By that reasoning, the great majority of jurists of both the Sunni and Shia traditions concluded that cannabis is forbidden. Attested
The question was not settled at once. Early jurists distinguished cannabis from wine in various ways, some debated whether it truly intoxicated or only stupefied, and arguments over its status ran for centuries. Attested Meanwhile its use spread. From the twelfth century onward hashish is widely recorded in Egypt, Syria, and lands further east, and it remained common across much of the Islamic world for hundreds of years, sometimes tolerated and sometimes harshly suppressed. Attested
The Plant That Danced
Medieval writers told a story of how hashish came to the dervishes. A Persian holy man of the twelfth century, an ascetic who had withdrawn from the world for many years, went walking alone one blazing day. Every plant in the field stood still in the heat except one, which swayed as though it were dancing. He picked its leaves and ate them, and returned to his disciples so merry and talkative that they hardly knew him. He showed them the plant and bade them keep its secret from all but the poor. Lore The holy man was real, and the dervishes who took his name were real. The story was recorded by medieval writers, and it is a legend. Attested Lore For a far older Persian story of a visionary drug, see The Seer's Cup.
Another tradition credits the plant to the mysterious Green One, the wandering immortal of Islamic folklore who appears to travelers and guides them. Lore The Green One is beloved across the Islamic world and is honored by many who would never touch the herb, and he should not be held responsible for it.
The Wandering Dervishes
Sufism is the inward and mystical tradition of Islam, and it has always contained many kinds of people. Most of the great Sufi orders taught sobriety and close keeping of the law. At their edges, from about the twelfth century, wandering groups of dervishes rejected ordinary society altogether. They shaved their heads and brows, went half naked or in rags, begged, and were accused by their critics of every kind of excess. Some of these groups were known for hashish, which they are said to have called the green one. Attested
A few voices defended it, in poems and treatises that praised it as an aid to contemplation and a key to hidden meanings. Attested The jurists answered fiercely. A famous jurist of fourteenth-century Damascus declared hashish worse than wine, said that it corrupted the mind and the character, and blamed its spread on foreign invaders. Attested
The Legend of the Assassins
In the eleventh to thirteenth centuries a branch of the Ismaili Shia held a chain of mountain fortresses in Persia and Syria, and defended themselves against far larger powers partly by the targeted killing of enemy leaders. Attested Their enemies called them by a word that means hashish users, and from that word comes the English word assassin. Attested The term was most likely an insult meaning something like rabble or riff-raff, used by those who hated them. Debated
The famous story came later. A European traveler of the late thirteenth century told of an old man of the mountain who drugged young men, carried them into a secret garden made to look like paradise, and then sent them out to kill, promising that they would return to that paradise if they obeyed. Attested No writing of the community itself mentions hashish, and modern historians largely regard the drugged garden as a legend shaped by enemies and travelers. Lore
It is worth pausing on how well this legend has served everyone except the truth. It gave Europe a thrilling story, it gave the community's enemies a weapon, and it gave a modern drug its most frightening association for centuries.
Today
Most Muslim scholars today hold that cannabis taken for intoxication is forbidden. Many permit medical use when a physician prescribes it and the law allows it, and many regard hemp products that do not intoxicate as permissible. Attested At the same time, cannabis remains part of ordinary life in some Muslim lands, and in a few places it has lingered at the edges of Sufi devotion. Attested One of those places, in northern Morocco, is noted in The Brotherhood of Hemp.
We do not take sides in a question of Islamic law, which belongs to those who keep it. We record the argument because it is honest, and because it shows something that the sellers of the plant prefer to forget: that for most of its history, the herb of the dervishes was loved by a few and opposed by nearly everyone with responsibility for the community. See The Sober Witnesses.
What the Record Teaches
Two lessons, I think. First, a sacred use of a plant can grow up at the margins of a tradition, among people who have rejected its center. That does not make it false, and it does not make it the tradition. Second, when the only witnesses are hostile, every story about the plant must be read twice: once for what it says, and once for who wanted it said.