The Cunning Folk
For most of European history, most people lived far from any trained physician and could not have paid one. When a child had a fever, a cow went dry, or a ring went missing, they went to someone in the village who knew things. English speakers called such a person a cunning man or a wise woman. Every language had its own word. Attested
Their work was a mixture that we would now sort into several trades. They knew herbs and set bones. Some attended births. They said charms over wounds, found lost property, told fortunes, and, importantly, they diagnosed and lifted bewitchment. Attested A great deal of practical plant knowledge lived with them, including knowledge of the powerful nightshades used for pain and sleep.
The Hunts
Trials for harmful magic were scattered through the Middle Ages, but the great persecutions belong to a later time than most people imagine: roughly 1450 to 1750, with the worst years falling between about 1560 and 1630. Attested
During the fifteenth century, learned writers fused old fears of harmful magic with a new and terrible idea: that witches belonged to a secret sect that had sworn itself to the devil, flew by night to assemblies, and worked to destroy society. Manuals for finding and trying such people circulated widely. Attested Once judges believed in the sect, each confession under torture produced the names of more members.
The best modern estimates are that between forty and sixty thousand people were put to death. Attested The figure of nine million, still sometimes repeated, comes from an eighteenth-century guess and has no basis. Lore The true number is quite terrible enough.
Who Was Accused
Across Europe as a whole, about three quarters of the accused were women. Attested They were often past middle age, often widowed or poor, and often known for a sharp tongue or a long quarrel with a neighbor. In a few regions, however, most of the accused were men. Attested
Most accusations did not begin with churchmen or judges. They began in the village, with a misfortune that someone needed to explain: a dead child, a blighted field, a sudden illness after an argument. And most trials were held in local secular courts. The large central courts, including the religious tribunals of southern Europe, were on the whole more skeptical and more lenient than village magistrates. Attested
Were the Victims the Healers?
A powerful modern story says that the witch hunts were a campaign to wipe out women healers and midwives, and with them an ancient knowledge of plants. You will find it in many books about witchcraft and in a few of the sources this library learned from.
The trial records do not support it. Debated Historians who have counted cases find that midwives were rarely accused and were more often called as trusted witnesses. Cunning folk were sometimes prosecuted, usually for fraud or superstition and with lighter sentences. Far more often they stood on the other side, as the experts whom frightened villagers consulted to identify the witch.
That does not mean the story is empty. Healers who failed, or who were thought to have turned their knowledge to harm, could find themselves accused. Women's authority over birth and sickness was genuinely eroded in these centuries as medicine became a licensed, male profession. Attested And an immense store of folk plant lore was lost, though more through neglect and contempt than through fire.
Plants in the Trials
Poisoning and witchcraft were closely linked in law and language. An accusation of harmful magic often involved powders, herbs, or ointments. Attested The famous flying ointment enters the record here, mostly through the writings of the learned. Its tangled evidence has a volume of its own: The Flying Ointment.
How It Ended
The hunts did not end because people stopped believing in witches. They ended because judges stopped trusting the evidence. Jurists grew uneasy about torture and about testimony that could not be checked. Central courts began overturning local convictions. By the late 1700s the executions had ceased almost everywhere in Europe. Attested
Why Accuracy Is a Form of Honor
Modern witches often claim the victims of the hunts as ancestors, and in spirit that is a generous and fitting act. But nearly all of the people who died were not witches in any sense. They were ordinary villagers who were hated or unlucky, and who went to their deaths protesting that they were innocent.
They are best honored by the truth: that fear looks for someone to blame, that the weak are blamed first, and that a court which accepts evidence that cannot be tested can be made to believe anything. That lesson is not antique.