In Brief

  • The belief that cannabis frees the creative mind is as old as the hashish circle of nineteenth-century Paris and as current as this year's sellers' pages.
  • When the claim is tested, small amounts change little and large amounts make original thinking worse. What the plant does reliably is make people feel more creative, and think better of ideas, their own and other people's.
  • A looser and more playful state has real uses at the beginning of a work. The finishing is done clear, and many working artists have said so themselves.

I edit other people's sentences for this library, and over the years I have learned to recognize a paragraph that was written late at night by someone who was delighted with it. Now and then it is the best paragraph in the piece. More often it is the one I have to send back with a gentle note. That is most of what I knew about cannabis and creativity before this month, and the research, as it turns out, agrees with me.

Two Centuries of Testimony

The belief that this plant frees the creative mind is older than it looks. In the 1840s a circle of writers and painters met each month in an old mansion on an island in the river at Paris, to eat a green paste of hashish under the eye of a physician who studied madness. Attested One of the poets among them later wrote the most searching account of it that we have. He concluded that hashish reveals to a person nothing but that person, magnified. He also concluded that it weakens the will, so that anyone who needs a poison in order to think will soon be unable to think without it. Attested See An Artificial Paradise.

The testimony continued. Jazz musicians in the America of the 1920s and 1930s said that the herb let them hear the music slowed and opened, with room between the notes. Attested The poets of the 1950s and the songwriters of the decades that followed said much the same. The music of the Rastafari carried the herb and the faith around the world together. Attested

The claim is still made, and three of the writings the keepers read in November 2026 made it. A collection of essays on cannabis and the spirit gave a chapter on creativity to a prizewinning novelist. A dispensary's page told its readers that the plant's compounds lead artists to profound revelations and to new expressions of spirituality. And a teacher's course promised to enhance and sharpen creative thinking, visioning, and artistic work. Attested

What Happens When It Is Tested

Psychologists cannot measure a poem, but they can measure one small part of what goes into it. They ask people to think of as many uses as they can for a common object, and they count the answers and judge how original they are.

In one experiment of this kind, published in 2015, regular users of cannabis were given a small amount, a large amount, or none at all. The small amount changed nothing. The large amount made their thinking markedly less original. Attested

Other studies have found that people who use cannabis do score a little higher on some tests of creativity when they are sober. The difference seems to belong to their temperament. They tend to be people who were more open to new experience to begin with. Attested

The most telling work appeared in 2022. People were assigned by chance to use cannabis either before or after a creative task. Those who used it first were more cheerful. They rated their own ideas as more creative. They rated other people's ideas as more creative too. Independent judges, who did not know who had used what, found no difference in the work. Attested

So the best attested effect of the plant on creativity is an effect on the judge and not on the work. This is the delighted paragraph of my opening, and it now has a study behind it.

These experiments have their limits, and it is fair to say so. A list of uses for a brick is not a painting. The studies are small, and no laboratory has followed a working artist through a year of work. What cannabis does to real art, made over months, has not been measured. Debated For the questions to put to any study, see Reading the Research.

What May Be Real

I do not think the artists were simply fooled. Several things that the plant does are well described, and each has a use at the beginning of a piece of work.

  • Sensation grows vivid. Music, color, and texture become absorbing, and an artist can study them closely. Attested
  • Associations multiply. One thought leads quickly to another, and some of the leaps are new. Attested
  • The inner critic goes quiet. For someone who cannot begin because nothing seems good enough, that can be a mercy.
  • Play returns. A good deal of making is play, and adults are short of it.

The losses are just as well described. The plant weakens the ability to hold a thing in mind, to keep attention on a task, and to carry it to the end. Attested Most of art is carrying it to the end.

The craft seems to have learned this already. Some of the witches whose practices are recorded on this shelf use the plant to dream up a working in a playful state, and then carry out the working itself only when sober. See The Green Ally in the Circle. Writers have an old rule that says the same in fewer words. Draft loosely and revise clearly.

Art as an Offering

Since this is a shelf about the spirit, one more thing should be said. Most sacred art has been made in a deliberate clarity. The painters of icons fast and pray before they take up the brush. The scribes who copy holy books wash before they write the name of God. Attested They do so because the hand must obey, and because the work is held to be a prayer in itself.

There is a second kind of sacred art, humbler and open to everyone, and that is the art of bringing an experience home. The drawing made the morning after, the page in the journal, and the song worked out slowly over a month are how a vision becomes part of a life. This library regards that work as the heart of the matter, and it is done clear. See Integration and The Journey Journal.

A Fair Test

If the plant is lawful where you live and is already part of your working life, you can find out what it does for your work without relying on anyone's opinion, including your own on the night.

  1. Keep everything, and mark it. Date each piece, and note on the back whether it was made clear or not.
  2. Wait a week. Then read it, look at it, or listen to it with a clear head.
  3. Ask an honest friend. Show them the work without telling them which is which, and see whether they can tell.
  4. Count what was finished. Beginnings are cheap. See how many pieces of each kind reached their end.
  5. Begin one piece clear. If you can no longer begin without the plant, you have learned the most important thing the test can show.

The Keeper's Counsel

The muse was never in the smoke. The poet said so first: the plant gives a person nothing but themselves, magnified. What it can do, for some people on some evenings, is hold a door open that fear or weariness had shut.

You still have to carry the work through that door. It is done with a clear head and both hands, on an ordinary morning, with a pencil for crossing out. I have come to think that the crossing out is where most of the art is.

About the Keeper

Imogen Lark, Keeper of the Threshold

Imogen is the library's editor and the first voice most seekers meet. She keeps the catalog, the glossary, and the path for new readers, and she sees that every correction is made.