A New Chair in an Old Room
When the research clinics reopened, their volunteers kept using words the clinicians had not been trained to answer. People spoke of God and of grace, of meeting their dead, of a unity they could not describe, of being forgiven. Many counted a single session among the most meaningful days of their lives. Attested See The Mystical Experience.
For a long time the clinic simply recorded such language. That has begun to change. One university center states that studies "consistently show" these substances improve emotional wellbeing by occasioning experiences that give people a deeper sense of meaning and purpose, and it argues that spirituality is therefore central to their promise as treatments. Attested Whether the spiritual experience causes the benefit, or only accompanies it, is still argued. Debated Either way, a room in which people regularly meet the holy needs someone in it who knows how to listen to that.
Two Clinicians, One Session
At that center, the work is built around what it calls a psycho-spiritual model. Each participant is accompanied by two co-therapists: a mental health clinician and a spiritual health clinician, the modern title for a professionally trained chaplain. The center describes itself as the first in the world to join clinical and research expertise in psychiatry and in spiritual care in this way. Attested
Others have joined the conversation. Chaplains have begun to argue in public that they belong in psychedelic therapy. A divinity school has established a program to study the traditions, ancient and modern, that seek to carry people beyond their ordinary states of consciousness and so to transform them, and through them their communities. Other projects have begun to place psychedelics in conversation with the teachings of the world's religious traditions. Attested
What a Chaplain Brings
A hospital chaplain is not a missionary. In most modern hospitals, chaplains serve patients of every faith and of none, and their training is in listening, not in preaching. Attested I spent nineteen years in that work, mostly at the bedsides of the dying, and its training fits the visionary room better than I would once have guessed. This is what I believe the chair asks of whoever sits in it.
- Presence without agenda. The chaplain does not need the person to arrive anywhere, to believe anything, or to feel better by a certain hour.
- Ease with mystery. Not rushing to explain. "I do not know" is an honest answer, and often the kindest one.
- Attention to meaning. Asking "What did that mean to you?" more often than "What did you see?"
- Many languages. Being able to hear a Catholic, a Muslim, a witch, and an atheist each in their own words, and to answer in theirs and not in one's own.
- Comfort with grief and with death. Visionary journeys often bring people face to face with their dead and with their own mortality. Someone in the room should not flinch.
- A sense of ritual. Knowing how to open and close a time, with a blessing, a silence, or a word of thanks, so that the day has edges. See Set, Setting and Sacred Containers.
At the End of Life
The oldest thread in the modern research runs through the rooms of the dying. Researchers have studied psilocybin for the anxiety and depression that can accompany a terminal illness, and the center described above expects end-of-life distress to be among the first uses to reach patients, alongside chronic pain, post-traumatic stress, depression that has resisted other treatment, addiction, and what it calls healthcare-induced demoralization. Attested How lasting the benefit is, and for whom, is still being studied. Debated Training in psychedelic care at the end of life is now offered to clinicians, and its advocates speak of making dying "a sacred and loving journey." Attested
I sat with the dying long before this research began again, and I want to say two things from that chair.
First, the fear of death is not a disease, and a good death is not a treatment outcome. A great many people die well without any sacrament at all, given honesty, company, relief from pain, and time. No one should be made to feel that they have failed to die properly because they did not have a vision.
Second, the dying are among the most vulnerable people there are. They are tired, often frail, often medicated, and surrounded by the hopes of those who love them. Any visionary work with them must be slower and more careful, not less, and their consent must be wholly their own.
Cautions from the Chair
The Word "Mystical" Is Not Settled
Scholars of religion have warned that the clinic's favorite word, mysticism, can flatten many different traditions into a single checklist, and that it carries analytical, therapeutic, and even legal complications. Debated A Christian contemplative, a Sufi, a Zen practitioner, and a peyote elder do not mean the same thing by their highest moments, and none of them would recognize their path in a questionnaire.
No One Should Be Converted
A person in a visionary state is open and suggestible. A spiritual companion who used that openness to plant a doctrine would betray the whole profession. Spiritual care belongs in the room only to serve the traveler's own meaning.
No One Should Be Argued Out of It Either
Equally, a person who has met something holy should not be told that it was only chemistry. What such experiences finally are is an open question, and both the clinic and the sanctuary should leave it open. See The Sacramental View.
Some Harms Are Spiritual
Researchers at the same center have proposed a framework for assessing adverse events in psychedelic therapies, arguing that harms must be counted as carefully as benefits. Attested A chaplain would add that some harms are spiritual: a lost faith, a terror of the void, a conviction of special mission, a sense of having been abandoned by God. These are real, they can last, and they deserve the same care as any other wound. See The Difficult Passage.
For Seekers Outside the Clinic
Most of our readers will never sit in a research room. But the chaplain's chair can be set beside any journey.
- If you sit for others, borrow the chaplain's habits: listen for meaning, let silence be, and keep your own beliefs out of another person's journey. See The Sitter's Guide.
- If a journey has left you with spiritual questions, consider speaking with a chaplain, minister, imam, rabbi, priestess, or other trained spiritual companion from your own tradition. Many are kinder and more open than you might expect.
- If you have no tradition, a spiritual director or a counselor experienced with such states can serve. Ask plainly whether they are comfortable hearing about a visionary experience.
A foundation in Berlin, borrowing a word from a German philosopher, speaks of the need for a Bewusstseinskultur, a "culture of consciousness": a culture that "examines the mental states of its members in an evidence-based way and assesses and cultivates them from an ethical perspective." Its public evenings are built in three parts: a critical discussion grounded in science, an experiential practice such as meditation or breathwork, and simple fellowship. Attested That is a good shape for a seekers' circle of any kind. Think clearly, practice humbly, and eat together afterward.