Every few months a reader asks us whether a church they have found online, one that holds cannabis as its sacrament, is real. We cannot answer for any particular church, and we name none. But we can describe the landscape, and we can offer the questions we would ask.
The Counterculture
In the 1960s, cannabis spread through a generation in the West at the same moment that Hindu and Buddhist teachers, yoga, and meditation arrived in force. Many young people felt that the herb and the teachings belonged together. The plant seemed to show them oneness, presence, and a world more forgiving than the one they had been taught, and the teachings seemed to explain what they had felt. Attested
A good number of that generation went on to become teachers of meditation, and many of them set the plant aside along the way, having found that practice could take them where the herb had only pointed. Attested One, ordained in a Zen lineage, writes with a smile that cannabis was indeed a gateway for him: it led him to the meditation cushion. That is a kind of testimony this library respects. It honors the door and does not mistake it for the house.
The New Churches
Since the 1970s, and especially since about 2010, dozens of small churches, temples, and ministries have been founded that name cannabis as their sacrament. Attested They range widely. Some have a theology, a liturgy, and a code of conduct. Some describe the plant itself as a manifestation of God. Some have little doctrine beyond the plant. Attested
- In the 1970s a small church in Jamaica and Florida called the herb its eucharist and claimed an oral tradition reaching back to ancient Ethiopia. Several of its leaders were convicted of smuggling large quantities of the plant, and in 1989 a federal appeals court in the United States refused the church any exemption. Attested
- In 2015, on the day a state religious-freedom law was signed in the American Midwest, a new church holding cannabis as its sacrament registered itself, and it was soon recognized as a religious organization for tax purposes. Its suit for the right to use the plant in worship failed in the state's courts. Attested
- On April 20, 2017, a date chosen for its meaning in cannabis culture, a church opened in an old church building in a city of the Rocky Mountains, its walls painted in bright murals. It describes itself as a home for those who use cannabis to find their best selves, and it has no fixed creed. Attested
Alongside these churches, cannabis appears in older and less organized devotions. Among devotees of the folk saint of death in Mexico and beyond, cannabis smoke is offered to her image and used in rites of purification, in some places taking the place of church incense. Attested
What the Courts Ask
In the United States, where most of these churches have arisen, the law protects the free exercise of religion, and since 1993 a federal statute has required the government to show a compelling interest before it substantially burdens a sincere religious practice. Attested On that ground the country's highest court protected a small church's sacramental use of an ayahuasca tea in 2006, and the peyote church of North America has had a legal exemption for decades. Attested See From Sacrament to Contraband.
Cannabis churches have almost always lost. Attested Courts ask two questions. First, is the belief truly religious, or is it a philosophy, a lifestyle, or a political conviction dressed in religious language? In a case of the mid-1990s a federal court set out a list of marks that distinguish a religion from other beliefs, and found that a self-described church of marijuana was not a religion at all but a belief about the plant. Attested Second, is the belief sincere, or is it a way around the law? Courts have looked hard at churches that sold their sacrament, admitted members for a fee, or were founded the week a new law passed. Attested Even where a religion has been judged sincere, courts have usually found that the government's interest in controlling the drug outweighs the claim. Attested
A Faith, a Club, or a Shop
We do not think the law's questions are the only ones, or the most important. A gathering can fail every legal test and still be a sincere and kind fellowship. A gathering can pass them and still be a trap. These are the questions we would ask.
- Is there more to it than the plant? Does the community teach anything about how to live, how to treat others, how to grieve, how to serve? If the only doctrine is the herb, it is a club. A club may be a fine thing. Call it a club.
- Does it ask anything hard of its members? Every living faith asks for something: honesty, generosity, discipline, service, forgiveness. A faith that asks only that you partake is asking very little.
- Does it sell the sacrament? A church that is also the only place to buy what it worships is a shop with a steeple.
- What does it say about harm? A community that holds a plant sacred should be the first to speak honestly about who should not use it. If it says the plant harms no one, it is not telling you the truth.
- Can you leave? Can you stop using the plant and still belong? Can you leave the community without being shamed?
- When was it founded, and why? A church born the week a law changed may be sincere. It should be able to tell you its story without mentioning the law.
For judging any organization you meet online, see Reading the Signposts.
The Keeper's View
We are a library and not a church, and we have no standing to say which churches are true. But I notice that the communities on this shelf that have held the herb sacred longest, the renunciants of Shiva and the Rastafari, did not begin with the plant. They began with a god, a scripture, a way of life, and a people, and the plant found its place inside them. The new churches often begin the other way around. That is not a judgment. It is a question worth carrying when you visit one.