In Brief

  • Ergot is a fungus of rye and other grains. Bread made from infected grain caused terrible epidemics in medieval Europe.
  • Midwives used small amounts to bring on labor, and in the twentieth century its alkaloids yielded important medicines and one famous psychedelic.
  • The theory that ergot poisoning caused the Salem witch panic of 1692 is ingenious, widely repeated, and doubted by most historians.

The Black Spur

In damp seasons, some of the grains in an ear of rye are replaced by hard, dark, curved bodies that resemble a rooster's spur. This is ergot, the resting stage of a fungus. Attested Ground into flour along with the good grain, it carries a set of potent alkaloids into the bread.

Ergot was no secret to farmers. What they did not understand for many centuries was what it did.

Holy Fire

The first clearly recorded epidemic struck the Rhine valley in the year 857, when a chronicler wrote of a plague of swollen blisters that consumed the people with a loathsome rot, so that their limbs loosened and fell away before death. Attested Outbreaks returned for centuries, especially in the rye-eating regions of France and Germany.

The sickness took two forms. In one, the alkaloids choked off the blood supply to hands and feet, which burned as if on fire, then blackened and dropped off. People called it holy fire. In the other, the nervous system was attacked, bringing convulsions, crawling sensations under the skin, and sometimes visions and madness. Attested

The link between the disease and spoiled rye was established only in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Attested A mass poisoning in a French town as late as 1951 was widely blamed on ergot, though that case is still argued. Debated

The Midwife's Powder

Ergot was also a medicine. A German herbal of 1582 records that midwives gave a few of the black grains to women in slow labor to strengthen the contractions. Attested The remedy was effective and dangerous, since a little too much could kill both mother and child. In later centuries physicians adopted it, and the alkaloids of ergot became the source of drugs still used to control bleeding after birth and to treat migraine. Attested

Here, for once, the tradition of women's plant knowledge is well documented. The wise women knew something that learned medicine took two hundred years to accept.

From the Granary to the Laboratory

In 1938 a chemist working through the derivatives of ergot alkaloids, in search of a medicine for circulation, prepared the twenty-fifth compound in his series and set it aside as unpromising. Five years later, in 1943, he returned to it, absorbed a trace by accident, and discovered the most potent psychedelic then known. The world came to call it LSD. Attested

LSD does not occur in ergot itself, and eating ergot does not produce its effects. This matters for what follows.

Salem

In the winter of 1692, several girls in a village of colonial Massachusetts began to suffer fits, to scream, and to complain of being pinched and bitten by invisible hands. They accused their neighbors of bewitching them. Before the panic ended, nineteen people had been hanged and one pressed to death. Attested

In 1976 a researcher proposed that the afflicted had been eating rye bread contaminated with ergot. Debated The theory is elegant. Convulsive ergotism does cause fits and crawling sensations. The village grew rye, and the preceding seasons had been wet.

Most historians have not been persuaded, for several reasons. Debated

  • Ergotism strikes households that share a loaf. At Salem the afflicted were a scattered handful, while their families stayed well.
  • The fits began and stopped on cue, in the courtroom, in the presence of the accused.
  • The other marks of ergot poisoning, such as gangrene and sickness of the stomach, are missing from the records.
  • Similar outbreaks of accusation happened in many places with no rye and no damp.

The older explanation remains the stronger one: a frightened community under strain from war, faction, and religious dread, in which accusation gave powerless young people sudden authority, and a court agreed to admit evidence that only the accusers could see.

The Temptation of the Chemical Answer

The Salem theory is repeated every autumn because it is satisfying. It turns a moral catastrophe into an accident of the weather. No one was cruel. It was the bread.

Those of us who love the history of visionary plants should be especially watchful for this temptation. Not every strange episode in the past was caused by a fungus. People are perfectly capable of persecuting one another without chemical assistance. A good historian of entheogens must be able to say, when the evidence requires it, that this time there was no plant in the story at all.

About the Keeper

Tobias Halloway, Keeper of the Record

Tobias is a folklorist and former parish archivist with a patient love for footnotes. He tends the history shelf and sets the three seals on every historical claim in the library.