In Brief

  • Recipes for witches' ointments were written down by learned men from the fifteenth century onward. That much is record.
  • Whether accused witches really made and used such ointments is seriously debated. The racy modern tale about broomsticks is legend.
  • The plants named in the recipes cause delirium and death. This history is to be read, never reenacted.

The Story as It Is Usually Told

You have probably heard it. Medieval witches brewed a salve of nightshades, rubbed it on their skin, and were carried off in visions to the sabbath. The broomstick was the applicator, and the flight was a drug dream.

It is a marvelous story, and parts of it stand on good evidence. Other parts stand on nothing at all. As Keeper of the Record, I will take it in three layers.

What the Record Shows

From the fifteenth century onward, physicians, natural philosophers, and writers on witchcraft recorded recipes for ointments that witches were said to use. The earliest surviving one known to us was written in the 1450s. Attested Ingredients vary, but certain plants recur: henbane, deadly nightshade, mandrake, hemlock, and monkshood, often with poplar buds or soot, in a base of fat. Attested

Several of those plants contain tropane alkaloids, which can pass through skin and which reliably produce delirium, a racing heart, a sensation of rising or falling, and a heavy sleep full of vivid dreams. Attested So the recipes are not nonsense. An ointment of that kind could indeed send a person on a terrible journey.

There are also a few accounts of trials. In the 1540s a physician reported that he obtained a jar of green ointment seized from an accused couple and tried it on a patient, who fell into a sleep so deep that she could hardly be roused for a day and a half, and who woke describing wild adventures. Attested The account is real. What it proves is that one learned man tested one ointment.

What Rumor Added

Here the ground softens. Almost every description of witches using ointment comes from the people who hunted them or from confessions taken under torture. Hardly any comes from an accused person speaking freely.

Scholars are divided. Debated Some hold that the recipes preserve a genuine folk practice of visionary salves, garbled by frightened clerics. Others point out that the ointment solved a puzzle for the learned: if witches confessed to flying, yet were seen asleep in bed, a drugged dream explained both. On that view the flying ointment is largely a theory invented by scholars and then extracted from prisoners.

The truth may lie between. Soporific salves made with nightshades were a real part of medieval medicine, used for pain and sleeplessness. Attested Some healers surely knew what a heavier hand would do. But there is no good evidence for the picture of thousands of village women anointing themselves for the sabbath.

What Legend Has Made of It

The tale that witches applied the ointment with a broomstick, in the most intimate manner possible, appears in countless articles every autumn. Lore It rests on very little. One later chronicle of a trial held in Ireland in 1324 mentions an ointment with which the accused greased a staff, and a fifteenth-century writer speaks of witches anointing a stick to ride. Attested Neither says what the modern story says. The lurid version took shape in the 1970s and has been repeated ever since because it is too good to check.

We do not mind a good legend. We do mind when a legend is used to sell jars.

Why the Story Still Matters

Even as legend, the flying ointment carries something true. It remembers that people have long sought to leave the body and travel in spirit, that plants were understood as doors, and that those in power feared any road to the unseen that did not pass through them.

A witch today can honor that memory without touching a nightshade. Flight was always a matter of the spirit. There are safer wings. See Sober Rites.

About the Keeper

Tobias Halloway, Keeper of the Record

Tobias is a folklorist and former parish archivist with a patient love for footnotes. He tends the history shelf and sets the three seals on every historical claim in the library.