The history shelf is mostly about great doors: the Mysteries, the mushroom velada, the century of discovery. This volume is about small ones, and about why the small ones are, in a way, the most instructive accounts on this shelf.
The Plant That Turned Inward
- Taken
- Cannabis, smoked, by someone who rarely used it
- Setting
- Lying down at home in a prepared space, with music, on two days running
- Company
- None during. His wife was told afterward
- Told
- To a camera, a few days later
The teller practices a body-centered form of spiritual therapy. Over ten years, he says, cannabis changed for him from something to relax with among friends into something that turned him inward whether he wished it or not, until he largely gave it up and became, by his own account, more afraid of it than of far stronger substances. A book describing guided sessions with the plant persuaded him that the experience could be held deliberately, and he set aside an afternoon to try.
Within seconds his hands began to move on their own. Then his attention narrowed to a point, like a laser pointer, and every point he attended to opened onto what he calls infinity. He followed each one out until he was, in his words, shot back to staring at the ceiling. After ten or so attempts to go beyond infinity, he accepted that he could not, and the points arranged themselves into the old black-and-white figure of balanced opposites. On the second day, small tensions in his body appeared to him as points holding pain. He turned toward them through a fear that he might die or never come back, and found himself, on accepting it, back in the room.
His summary is lovely: "Every infinity loop has to come back to where it started." Some of his claims are harder to weigh. He counts "well over a hundred" deaths of the ego and wonders aloud whether they count, which is a fair question about a phrase now used very freely. He believes his stiff neck was eased that evening by the attention he gave it. And he hopes to bring the plant into his work with others.
What Can Be Said
Cannabis has been used in religious practice in South Asia for a very long time. Attested Its sacred history, and the faiths that refuse it, are kept on the cannabis shelf. It acts chiefly on the body's cannabinoid receptors, not on the serotonin receptor through which the classic visionary substances work, and it is usually classed apart from them. Attested Whether it should be called a psychedelic is a matter of argument; strong amounts, especially in people who seldom use it, can bring vivid inward states that some describe in mystical terms. Debated Attention can change how pain is felt. Attested That pain is stored in points in the body and released by looking at it belongs to the teller's own tradition. Lore
Cannabis also brings panic and acute anxiety to many people. Attested Strong and frequent use is associated with a higher risk of psychosis, and a personal or family history raises that risk further. Attested It is also among the recognized triggers of a lasting sense that oneself or the world is unreal. Attested Many accounts elsewhere on this shelf mention it as the thing that deepened or darkened a journey taken with something else. See Medications and Conditions.
Twenty-Eight Days
- Taken
- Very small amounts of a visionary substance, most mornings, for four weeks
- Setting
- Ordinary life: home, garden, and work
- Company
- Some friends who tried the same, whose results were never reported
- Told
- In a sponsored science video
The teller makes videos about science and old ways of living. He took very small amounts most mornings for four weeks and reported what he noticed. He got organized in ways that had escaped him for over a year. On the days he took it, everything, he says, "looked prettier, especially outside." Tedious work in the garden became pleasant, his general impatience eased, and the negative chatter in his head grew quieter. He also noticed a downside: a slight drop in his ability to solve complex problems, especially on days when he took a little too much, and he warns viewers to think twice about driving.
His conclusion was refreshingly unambitious. He did not think he needed to continue. "I got what I needed out of it," he says. The video also directs viewers to a coach, an app, a book, and the teller's own guide, while saying that he cannot recommend anything because it is against the law. We note the mixed message without unkindness. It is common.
The experiment had no comparison, no measure, and no blinding. The teller knew every morning what he had taken, and he had been told by several people beforehand what he would probably feel.
The Problem of Expectation
That is not a criticism of him. It is the central problem of all testimony, and the small doors show it most clearly, because the effects they promise are subtle enough that hope alone could produce them.
Researchers have tested this. In 2021 a study enlisted people who were already taking very small amounts and had them blind themselves, mixing real capsules with empty ones so that they did not know which they took on a given day. Those taking the empty capsules improved on most measures about as much as those taking the real ones, and how much people improved followed what they believed they had taken. Attested Laboratory trials, and a trial in which people took small amounts at home for six weeks, have mostly found no benefit over placebo for mood, well-being, creativity, or thinking. Attested Many participants could tell when they had received the real thing, which weakens the blind and shows that these amounts are not inert. Attested Whether people with particular conditions might benefit, and what years of repeated small amounts might do to the body, are open questions still being studied. Debated
None of this means the teller imagined his tidy shelves or his pleasure in the garden. It means that a month of hopeful mornings, carefully attended to, may do much of that work on its own.
What the Quiet Accounts Teach
- Expectation is powerful. It does not make an account false, and it makes any single account a poor guide to cause. See On Reading Testimony and Reading the Research.
- Small is not nothing. Both tellers noticed effects on thinking, and the law, in most places, treats a small amount no differently from a large one.
- Stopping is a skill. "I got what I needed out of it" is one of the wisest sentences on this shelf.
- The attention may be the gift. Noticing that the garden is beautiful, turning gently toward a tight muscle, letting the chatter quiet: these are also the oldest practices of contemplation, and none of them requires a substance. See Sober Rites.