I have led many rites and taught a good deal of plain sitting, and the question I hear most from people who use cannabis is whether it is cheating to meditate high. I do not think cheating is the right word. The better question is whether it is the same practice at all.
An Old Pairing
The renunciants of Shiva have smoked the herb before meditation and chanting for a very long time, and the Rastafari reason with it. Attested In the West, the pairing of cannabis with meditation dates mostly from the 1960s, when the herb and the teachings of Asia arrived together for a whole generation. Attested Today it is sold as a pairing too. Shops offer products for the morning meditator and the evening yogi, and the pages of sellers promise that the plant will quiet the mind, open the third eye, and make the present moment luminous.
The contemplative traditions themselves are more cautious. The fifth precept of lay Buddhists is to abstain from intoxicants that lead to heedlessness, and the older schools keep it strictly. Attested Other schools interpret it differently, but nearly every living teacher of meditation we know of asks students to sit with a clear mind. Attested See The Sober Witnesses.
What the Herb Does to Attention
A good deal is known about how cannabis changes the mind in the short term. It tends to slow the felt passage of time. Attested It makes sensations vivid, so that music, taste, and touch can become absorbing. Attested It weakens the ability to hold information in mind for a short while and to keep attention steady on a task. Attested It tends to multiply associations, so that one thought leads quickly to another. Attested And its effects on mood are not simple: small amounts relax many people, while larger amounts, or the same amounts in a different person or setting, can bring anxiety and even panic. Attested
You will read that cannabis quiets the network of brain regions most active when the mind wanders and dwells on itself, as experienced meditators learn to do. Studies of meditators have found changes in that network, and sellers sometimes borrow those findings for the plant. Attested Whether cannabis does anything similar during meditation has not, so far as we know, been shown. Debated
A survey of more than a thousand adults who used cannabis found that those who meditated were more likely to say the plant had brought them spiritual benefit. Attested That could mean that the plant helps meditators. It could also mean that meditators are more inclined to look for meaning in any experience, or that those who found the two incompatible stopped combining them. Debated See The Green Sacrament.
Absorption and Awareness
Here is the distinction I find most useful.
Absorption is being swallowed by an experience. The song fills the whole world. The candle flame becomes fascinating. A thought becomes a cathedral of thoughts. Absorption can be beautiful and even holy, and the herb is very good at it.
Awareness is the quiet capacity to notice what is happening, including that one has been swallowed, and to return. It is the thing meditation trains, slowly, over thousands of small returns to the breath. It is not exciting. It is what lets a person stay steady in grief, in anger, or in a hospital corridor.
The trouble is that vivid absorption feels like deep meditation, and the herb weakens the very faculty that would notice the difference. A person can spend an hour delighted by the patterns of their own thoughts and rise believing they have sat well. One writer who had once leaned on the plant put it simply: it could take them somewhere, but it could not teach them how to get there again without it.
Two Cushions
If cannabis is lawful where you live, and it is already part of your life, and you would like to know honestly what it does to your practice, here is a simple way to find out without fooling yourself.
- Build the clear cushion first. Sit without any substance, most days, for at least a full moon before you consider anything else. You need a baseline, and the baseline is the practice. A practitioner we read put it plainly: learn to meditate without the plant first.
- Keep the clear cushion always. If you ever sit with the herb, let it be the rare exception and never the rule. A practice that cannot happen without a substance has become a practice of the substance.
- Write it down the same evening. After any sitting with the herb, note what happened, and then what you would say about it if you had been sober. Read the notes a week later. See The Journey Journal.
- Ask what came home. Did the sitting leave you kinder, steadier, more honest the next day? Or did it leave only a pleasant memory and a wish to repeat it? Fruit is the only measure we trust. See Integration.
- Notice if you cannot sit without it. If the clear cushion has become hard to bear, that is important information. It is not a moral failure. See Setting It Down.
The Keeper's Counsel
Many people first discover that the present moment is interesting while under the influence of this plant, and I would not take that discovery away from anyone. But the discovery is not the practice. The practice is learning to find the present moment on a dull Tuesday, sober, tired, and unimpressed, and to stay there for one more breath. No herb can do that part for you, and the good news is that none is needed. See Sober Rites. For the same question asked of the body, see The Herb and the Mat.