An Old Form
It is tempting to think of the trip report as a child of the internet: a young person in front of a camera, talking about last weekend. The form is much older than that. People have been setting down, in the first person and in order, what happened to them in a visionary state for nearly two centuries, and the habits of those early writers are still visible in every account on this shelf.
In 1845 a French physician who studied madness published a book on hashish in which he argued that the only way to understand its effects was to take it oneself and observe. Attested In 1857 a young American published a long book on his own hashish years, part rapture and part warning. Attested In 1860 a French poet gathered his writings on hashish and opium under the title Artificial Paradises, and the phrase has followed the subject ever since. Attested
The peyote cactus entered this literature in the 1890s. In 1896 an American physician and novelist described his own visions of the cactus in a medical journal. Attested The account that most readers remember came a little later, from England.
Good Friday, 1897
- Taken
- The dried tops of the peyote cactus, then sold as mescal buttons
- Setting
- His own rooms in London, by firelight and gaslight
- Company
- None. A pencil and a notebook
- Told
- In a medical journal in 1897, and at length in a literary monthly in January 1898
On Good Friday of 1897 an English physician and essayist, already known for his writing on psychology, sat down alone in his rooms with a quantity of mescal buttons and a pencil. Attested He took them in the afternoon and wrote as he went.
The first hours were mostly of the body. He felt a rush of energy and intellectual power, then faintness and a slow pulse, and he lay down with a book. A violet shadow floated over the page. When he closed his eyes, the darkness filled first with vague movements of light and then with patterns that never repeated themselves. By evening he was watching, in his own words, "a vast field of golden jewels, studded with red and green stones, ever changing." The forms bloomed into things like flowers, like the wings of insects, like what he called "living arabesques."
He did not sleep. Every sense was sharpened, and he admitted to a vague alarm at the sheer novelty of it all. The gas flame seemed to send out waves, and the shadows in the room turned violet, so that the walls looked painted. In the small hours the visions faded. He slept peacefully, woke without fatigue, and wrote that he had been more sensitive to beauty ever since.
A saturnalia of the specific senses, and above all an orgy of vision.
The physician's own summary, 1898
The Artist and the Poet
The essay does not end with the writer's own afternoon. He gave the cactus to others and recorded what they told him, and their testimony is harder reading.
An artist friend, after a first attempt seemed to do nothing, took more. He felt pain about the heart and was sure that he was dying. Colors had tastes. His body seemed wrapped in blue flame, and he saw his own face as if it hung inside a paper lantern, and then a skull. He was brought round with brandy, coffee, and a biscuit, and by the sound of his own voice, and he slept badly for three nights afterward. Attested The essay also records a poet who saw dragons and walked the riverbank at night entranced by a lighted sign, and it mentions without much concern that a poet with a weak heart was among those who tried it.
No keeper of this library would have handed the cactus to a friend with a weak heart, or met a frightened traveler with brandy. We record these things because the essay records them, and because they show how little the danger was understood by the very people who were writing it down.
What He Concluded
The physician's verdict was measured. He judged that mescal was unlikely to become a habit, that it asked for sound health in the one who took it, and that a healthy person might take it once or twice in safety, though habitual use would be gravely injurious. He called it the most democratic of the plants, because it cast what he called "a halo of beauty" around the simplest and commonest things, and he thought its natural poet would be the poet of the English lakes.
Some of this has worn well. The low tendency of the classic visionary plants to form a habit is supported by modern study. Attested So is his caution about the heart, which his own friends demonstrated. Other conclusions have not worn so well. He insisted that the mind remained a calm and self-possessed spectator throughout, and many later travelers, including the frightened artist in his own essay, would disagree. Debated He also admitted, to his credit, that everything he said rested on very small experience.
The essay is a document of its time in another way. It speaks of the Native peoples who kept the cactus in the language of a colonial power, and it treats their sacrament as a curiosity to be sampled in a London sitting room, without ceremony and without thought of what was owed. The reader should hold its beauty and its blindness together. See Guardians of the Sacred Plants for what that cactus faces today.
From Pencil to Camera
In the twentieth century the form moved from the medical journal to the bookshop. In 1954 an English novelist published a short and widely read book about an afternoon with mescaline, and in 1957 a popular picture magazine carried a long first-person account of a mushroom ceremony in Mexico. Attested Both did a great deal to send outsiders looking for the sacraments, and the cost of that is told in The Little Saints.
In the 1990s the reports moved again, onto the early internet, where anyone could write one. By the turn of the century a nonprofit archive had begun to collect, review, and catalog first-person reports, and in time it held tens of thousands of them. Attested Researchers have since read such archives in bulk, sorting thousands of reports by the words their writers chose, to compare one substance with another. Attested In the last fifteen years the report has moved once more, to video, where it is spoken rather than written and is measured, for better and for worse, by how many people watch.
What the Old Account Still Teaches
Set the Victorian essay beside a video recorded last spring and the bones are the same. There is the decision and the taking. There is the waiting, the first stirrings in the body, the climb, the summit, and the long descent into the small hours. There is the sleep, the morning, and the claim that something has been changed for good. The camera has replaced the pencil, and very little else has moved.
The cautions have not moved either. The physician could not know the strength of what he took. He was alone. He passed it to friends who were less fortunate than he was. And he drew large conclusions from his own temperament. Every one of those patterns returns in the modern accounts on this shelf, which is why we begin with him. For how to weigh any account, old or new, read On Reading Testimony.